Garmin Vivofit 2 vs. Garmin Vivosmart HR Comparison

Most fitness trackers nowadays can perform a wide range of functions, such as smartphone interaction and physical activity assistance. Yet, they become a vital role in your daily life. What’s on your mind right now may be the consideration between Garmin Vivofit 2 vs. Garmin VivoSmart HR. Which one is better? Which one should you buy, Garmin Vivofit 2, or Garmin VivoSmart HR?
Don’t worry. We got your back. In this article, we will layout 6 of the essential criteria for when it comes to choosing a fitness tracker. Also, we will compare head-to-head Garmin Vivofit 2 vs. Garmin VivoSmart HR and help you refine your buying decision. Stay tuned and read on!

6 Considerations When Choosing Garmin Vivofit 2 vs. Garmin Vivosmart HR


Criteria           Garmin Vivofit 2Garmin Vivosmart HR
Dust-proof and water-resistantYesYes
Display/TouchscreenYes/NoYes/ Yes
Water-proof depth rating50m50m

First of all, the design is where you obviously put a lot of consideration into as you are after all going to be living with it day and night, in the shower or in the pool and in the gym too. So the first thing we’re going to mention is durability. Both Garmin Vivofit 2 and Garmin Vivosmart HR offer most core protections such as dust-proofing, sweat-resistance, and water-resistance to meet your requirement. For those who are diving, you might be pleased as the water-proof depth threshold they can withstand is up to 50m.

Turning to the comparison, both possess display for you to see the current state details, but Garmin Vivosmart HR outperforms its predecessor by a touchscreen. The weight gap between those two is not quite noticeable, Garmin Vivosmart HR is just 4.1g heavier than Garmin Vivofit 2.

So yes, there is an extra touchscreen feature on Garmin Vivosmart HR to monitor the watch directly on your wrist, but when we talk about efficiency, you can see that those two are quite alike.


Criteria           Garmin Vivofit 2Garmin Vivosmart HR
Heart rate monitorYesYes

Turning to the sensors, which is one of the weaknesses of a fitness tracker. Garmin Vivo Fit 2 and Garmin Vivosmart HR merely possess the essential sensors like heart rate monitor and accelerometer, and that is.

Activity tracking

Criteria           Garmin Vivofit 2Garmin Vivosmart HR
Distance trackingYesYes
Walking step taken trackingYesYes
Sleep trackingYesYes
Sleep reportingYesYes
Calories burnt trackingYesYes
Pace trackingYesYes
Activity reportsYesYes
Elevation trackingYesYes
Route trackingYesYes
Goal setting modeYesYes
Exercise taggingYesYes
Weight trackingYesYes
Water intake trackingYesYes
Automatic activity detectionYesNo

Regards to activity tracking, health, and fitness tracking are what Garmin does best, and there is nothing to separate these two in that department. Both offer the same core sports tracking modes, which include running, cycling, and other features to support the exercises like calorie tracking, goal setting, weight tracking, water intake tracking, and so on. The sleep tracking is also provided by Garmin Vivofit 2 and Garmin Vivosmart HR, which use your heart rate to unlocks further sleep insights like REM cycles and sleep quality.

The only difference here to mention is you must go manually for choosing the sport you play in advance on Garmin Vivosmart HR, while Garmin Vivofit 2 offers a little more convenience for you by adding the automatic activity detection feature.


Criteria           Garmin Vivofit 2Garmin Vivosmart HR
Android compatibleYesYes
iOS compatibleYesYes
Syncs wirelesslyYesYes
Automatically syncsYesYes
Bluetooth version44
Windows compatibleNoYes
Mac OS X compatibleNoYes

There also are not radical differences here in the connectivity section. Garmin Vivosmart HR still retains those smart features of Garmin Vivofit 2, such as the ability to sync wirelessly and automatically, Bluetooth version 4, and the Android and iOS compatibility. The step-ups were made here is the synchronization between Garmin Vivosmart HR and laptop with Windows and Mac OS X platforms. It is the solid works, but yet they are not revolutionary worth your consideration.


Criteria           Garmin Vivofit 2Garmin Vivosmart HR
Battery life365 days5 days
Battery level indicatorNoYes
Rechargeable batteryNoYes

In terms of the battery, Garmin Vivosmart HR made a huge step-up here compared to its predecessor. Garmin Vivosmart HR advances to the rechargeable battery with the battery level indicator to see the current state of the battery capacity. But old-fashion technology still has its own advantage. Garmin Vivofit 2 can muster up to 365 days, it is a ridiculous amount of battery life of a smart fitness tracker, compared to just 5 days of Garmin Vivosmart HR.


Criteria           Garmin Vivofit 2Garmin Vivosmart HR
Phone locatingNoYes
Sync to the cloudYesYes
Silent alarmNoYes
Exercise diaryYesYes
Integrates with social networksYesYes
Inactivity alertsYesYes
Achievement trackingYesYes
Access to online servicesYesYes
Social featuresYesYes
Free AD-free appYesYes
Support routeYesYes
Music playbackYesYes
BMI trackingYesYes
Support widgetYesYes

Talking to features, Garmin Vivofit 2 and Garmin Vivosmart HR possess some fundamental features to support your exercise like a built-in stopwatch, inactivity alerts, achievement tracking. They both come with a free dedicate app that where you can sync your workout data. The app also offers an exercise diary, social features, route tracking, widget, BMI tracking, and music playback. The upgrades of Garmin Vivosmart HR made in the notification information and silent alarm, which you might find it less annoying way to wake you up. Moreover, in case you misplace your phone in nowhere, Garmin Vivosmart HR can help you with that through a phone locating feature.

Verdict: Garmin Vivofit 2 vs. Garmin Vivosmart HR – Which One Should You Choose?

At the bottom line, for fitness purposes, both Garmin Vivofit2 and Garmin Vivosmart HR can serve you well, and in this section, we probably give it a draw. The most significant upgrade is made here that worth your consideration, is the battery where you can recharge and know your current capacity.

Choosing Garmin Vivosmart HR if:

  • You need incredibly long battery longevity
  • You need to find a fitness tracker that provides sufficient data insights with a low budget.

Choosing Garmin Vivosmart HR if:

  • You like those up-to-date features like a touchscreen and rechargeable battery.
  • You want to widen your device ecosystem, especially with a laptop, by synchronizing the fitness tracker with it.