Fitbit Charge vs Garmin Vivofit 2 Comparison

Most fitness trackers nowadays can perform a wide range of functions, such as smartphone interaction and physical activity assistance. Yet, they become a vital role in your daily life. What’s on your mind right now may be the consideration between Fitbit Charge vs Garmin Vivofit 2. Which one is better? Which one should you buy, Fitbit Charge or Garmin Vivofit 2?

Don’t worry. We got your back. In this article, we will layout 6 of the essential criteria for when it comes to choosing a fitness tracker. Also, we will compare head-to-head Fitbit Charge vs Garmin Vivofit 2 and help you refine your buying decision. Stay tuned and read on!

6 Considerations When Choosing Fitbit Charge vs Garmin Vivofit 2

Design

Criteria           Fitbit ChargeGarmin Vivofit 2
Dust-proof and water-resistantYesYes
Sweat-resistantYesYes
Display/TouchscreenYes/NoYes/No
Water-proof depth rating10m50m
Width21mm21mm

Both Fitbit Charge, who is a newcomer of this fitness tracker, and Garmin Vivofit 2 feature all the essential endurance such as dust-proofing, sweat-resistance, and water-resistance to suit your most sporty needs. They also possess the display to show your stats, but both screens are pretty low grade, low-resolution grey-scale – and neither are touchscreen. The width is similar across both models (21mm), barely noticeable on your wrist. The major difference between Fitbit Charge and Garmin Vivofit 2 is that if you are primarily concerned with their water-proof depth withstandable threshold to serve your diving session, Garmin Vivofit 2 is probably for you which is 50m of Garmin Vivofit 2 and just 10m of Fitbit Charge.

Sensors

Criteria           Fitbit ChargeGarmin Vivofit 2
Heart rate monitorNoYes
AccelerometerYesYes

There is nothing much to mention here, as this section is not a sweet point of fitness tracker. Both possess the accelerometer, but Fitbit Charge 2 is held back by the lack of heart rate monitor compared to its rival. This feeds into the vast array of advanced training insights and analysis on Garmin Vivofit 2.

Activity tracking

Criteria           Fitbit ChargeGarmin Vivofit 2
Distance trackingYesYes
Walking step taken trackingYesYes
Sleep trackingYesYes
Sleep reportingYesYes
Calories burnt trackingYesYes
Pace trackingNoYes
Activity reportsYesYes
Elevation trackingYesYes
Route trackingNoYes
Goal setting modeYesYes
Exercise taggingYesYes
Weight trackingYesYes
Calorie intake trackingYesNo
Automatic activity detectionNoYes

Regards to activity tracking section, let’s start by covering of the similar features. Both Fitbit Charge and Garmin Vivofit 2 offer core fitness tracking: distance, walking step, calorie burnt, elevation, goal setting, weight, which feed into the activity reports afterward. They possess the sleep tracking, but Fitbit Charge’s sleep tracking is merely accelerometer-based, not as accurate and thorough as that of Garmin Vivofit 2. Both also can be manually set to capture a particular type of exercise, yet you can get a little bit more convenience on Garmin Vivofit 2 with automatic exercise recognization. The differences are that pace tracking, and route tracking is only fitted into Garmin Vivofit 2, while Fitbit Charge supports calorie intake tracking.

Connectivity

Criteria           Fitbit ChargeGarmin Vivofit 2
Android compatibleYesYes
iOS compatibleYesYes
Windows compatibleYesNo
Syncs wirelesslyYesYes
Automatically syncsYesYes
Mac OS X compatibleYesNo
Bluetooth version44

The connectivity set across the two devices are actually quite similar. Fitbit Charge and Garmin Vivofit 2 both support the Android and iOS platforms, opens the compatibility with a vast proportion of devices currently. The ability to sync wirelessly and automatically are also fitted into both models. Yet Fitbit Charge broadens its connectivity border beyond the laptop segment, with the Windows and Mac OS X compatibility.

Battery

Criteria           Fitbit ChargeGarmin Vivofit 2
Battery life7 days365 days
Rechargeable batteryYesNo

There is a significant distinction to mention here. Fitbit Charge steps up to the rechargeable battery with the promise to last up to seven days. Garmin Vivofit 2 still sticks to the old-fashion battery, yet it has its own advantage that Garmin Vivofit 2 can remain function the whole year round, letting Garmin Vivofit stay on your wrist for an extremely long time between battery replacement.

Features

Criteria           Fitbit ChargeGarmin Vivofit 2
NotificationYesNo
Silent alarmYesNo
StopwatchYesYes
Integrates with social networksYesYes
Inactivity alertsYesYes
Achievement trackingYesYes
Access to online servicesYesYes
Social featuresYesYes
Exercise diaryYesYes
Free AD-free appYesYes
Sync to the cloudYesYes
External heart rate monitor compatibleYesYes
Music playbackYesYes
Supports routeNoYes
BMI trackingNoYes
Predict ovulationYesNo
Designed for womenYesNo

Things are quite familiar and similar across Fitbit Charge and Garmin Vivofit 2 in the features. Stopwatch, social networks integration, achievement tracking, online services, social features are all offered by both devices. They also come with the free AD-free apps to support and sync the data with plenty of built-in features like external heart rate monitor compatibility, music playback, and exercise diary.

On the other hand, sorely Fitbit Charge 2 has onboard notification and silent alarm, while it misses out the BMI tracking and route support in its app, compared to that of its competitor. Moreover, Fitbit Charge opens up the whole new audience of potential buyers by the addition of the specifications for women, which Fitbit is well-known with that.

Verdict: Fitbit Charge vs Garmin Vivofit 2 – Which One Should You Choose?

At the bottom line, people can look down at Fitbit Charge as a newbie, yet the performance it delivers is relatively interesting and promising. Otherwise, Garmin Vivofit 2 still manages to retain its reputation as the best fitness tracker among the market.

Choosing Fitbit Charge if:

  • You need to sync your data and analytics to the laptop.
  • You are interested in the battery advance.
  • You need specifications for women.

Choosing Garmin Vivofit 2 if:

  • You are after the most well-served fitness tracker.
  • You need a vast amount of data insights, and it must be thorough as well.
  • You need an incredibly long battery life.